Skip to content

Executive summary

Executive Summary of the D21 Voting Contract - System Security Assessment

Overview

This security assessment focused on evaluating the D21 voting system, a blockchain-based platform designed to implement the D21 voting method. The assessment encompassed various testing methodologies to ensure a thorough evaluation of the system's security, functionality, and user experience.

Key Findings

  1. Fuzz Testing: The system successfully passed fuzz testing, showing resilience to a wide range of inputs and scenarios. No vulnerabilities or errors were detected.

  2. Manual Code Review: Revealed two areas for potential improvement:

    • The getRemainingTime function's return value could be misinterpreted when voting has not started.
    • The getResults function lists subjects with zero votes before the voting begins, which might cause confusion.

  3. Tool-Based Analysis: Identified a high-severity warning about an unchecked return value in the sorting function, underscoring the need for robust error handling.

Implications

  • The system demonstrates robustness and reliability in handling complex voting scenarios, as evidenced by the successful fuzz testing.
  • The manual code review's findings suggest a need for slight modifications to improve user clarity and prevent potential misunderstandings.
  • The tool-based analysis points to a critical area in error handling that requires attention to ensure system stability and integrity.

Recommendations

  • Code Refinement: Address the issues identified in the manual code review to enhance user experience and clarity.
  • Error Handling: Modify the code to handle the unchecked return value, reinforcing the system's resilience to errors.

Conclusion

Overall, the D21 voting system exhibits a strong foundation in security and functionality. The identified issues are not indicative of fundamental flaws but rather areas for refinement.